How are football player ratings calculated?
Apps run an algorithm over the events a data provider records, and the method pages we read don't publish the weights.

On this page
Sofascore's help centre says its ratings are "not entered manually by members of our team" and that a machine learning algorithm values each offensive, defensive and goalkeeping action. We read the method pages of Sofascore, WhoScored, FotMob and Flashscore, and none publishes its weights.
How is a rating calculated?
An algorithm gives each recorded event a value and moves a starting score up or down. Sofascore says every player starts at 6.5. WhoScored says its ratings are out of 10, starting from 6.0, and Flashscore's announcement gives "a base rating of six". FotMob's FAQ states no starting value.
The weights, meaning how much a tackle or a pass is worth, are on none of those pages, so you can't recompute a rating yourself.
What does each app say about its ratings?
Soccerway's App Store listing names "unique player ratings" and doesn't describe how they are calculated.
| App | Starting value | Minimum time on pitch |
|---|---|---|
| Flashscore | "A base rating of six" | At least ten minutes, extra time not counted |
| FotMob | Not stated on the FAQ | Not stated on the FAQ |
| Soccerway | Not described | Not described |
| Sofascore | 6.5 | 10 minutes for the first ratings |
| WhoScored | 6.0 | Not stated on the page |
Flashscore. Its announcement says goals, shots on goal, passes, duels won and tackles "add extra tenths", while fouls, cards and lost duels lower the rating. Team shots, the match result and position also count.
FotMob. The FAQ says the rating is "calculated based on more than 300 individual stats per player per match …". It gives no scale or weights.
Sofascore. The algorithm "analyses hundreds of data points" in five categories: shooting, passing, dribbling, defending and goalkeeping. It also says "1 out of 3000 performances gets the perfect rating", its own figure.
WhoScored. "Over 200 raw statistics" go in, "weighted in relation to its area on the pitch and its outcome". A goal scored or conceded and a clean sheet at 90 minutes can raise or lower the rating, and so can position and time on the pitch.
Why does the same player get different ratings in different apps?
Starting values and inputs differ and no weights are published, so the same 7.0 can mean different things in two apps.
Ball, Huynh and Varley fitted statistical models to 73 performance metrics for more than 2,100 players over two seasons in top European leagues. Their 2025 abstract doesn't name the leagues or seasons. It reports that WhoScored ratings were systematically lower, that the three systems "are not directly interchangeable", and that offensive metrics such as shots on target had the largest effect on ratings.
A lower average shows the systems run at different levels. It doesn't show which one is closer to the truth, and none of our sources provides a "correct" rating to compare against.
What do ratings miss?
They capture the events the provider records, and on some pages the team's result too. WhoScored adjusts for goals scored or conceded and a clean sheet. Flashscore says team shots and the match result count. The Sofascore and FotMob pages we read don't mention it.
Gelade and Hvattum (2020) report in their abstract that event-level statistics "can explain from 22% to 38% of the variance in plus-minus ratings, depending on player positions". Plus-minus ratings, per Hvattum's 2019 review, "attempt to distribute credit for the performance of a team onto the players". The abstract doesn't settle whether the gap is a flaw in plus-minus or in event counts.
McHale, Scarf and Folker's abstract on the EA Sports Player Performance Index (2012) says "players from leading teams lead the index". Our inference is that team strength can leak into individual ratings.
Do algorithm ratings agree with journalists' ratings?
Partly, and the two studies we found put the agreement at different levels.
García-Fernández and Quian (2026) compared Sofascore and Flashscore with two European outlets for 60 players in 10 high-profile matches in 2024-25. Their abstract reports mean ratings of 6.76 for the outlets, 7.53 for Sofascore and 7.33 for Flashscore, a correlation of about 0.72 between the outlets and the algorithms, and no significant difference by position. The authors call the two kinds of rating "epistemologically complementary".
Silva and colleagues (2023) studied the last five games of the 2021/22 Portuguese first division. Correlations between three newspapers, and between the newspapers and Sofascore, ran from 0.54 to 0.64, and one newspaper's goalkeeper mean was 2.85 against 5.7 to 5.8 for the other two, so scales differ between outlets.
We read only abstract-level reporting of both studies.
Is there a standard way to rate players?
No. Pappalardo and colleagues write in the 2019 abstract of their PlayeRank method that there is "no consolidated and widely accepted metric" for measuring performance quality.
How should you read a rating?
Use it as a rough summary of recorded actions, inside one app. This advice is our inference.
- Compare players within one app, because starting values and inputs differ.
- Compare players in the same position where you can, because WhoScored says position affects the rating.
- Read the rating next to the match. A high number from an app that counts team results can partly reflect the scoreline.
Our football stats apps comparison lists what each app's own pages say about ratings.
Frequently asked questions
Are player ratings done by a human or a computer?
A computer. Sofascore's help centre says its ratings are "not entered manually by members of our team" and come from a machine learning algorithm. WhoScored describes a statistical algorithm calculated live, and Flashscore describes tenths added or taken off for recorded actions. None of the method pages we read publishes the weights.
Why does Sofascore start at 6.5 and WhoScored at 6.0?
Neither page says why. Sofascore says every player starts a match at 6.5, and WhoScored says its ratings are out of 10, starting from 6.0. Flashscore's announcement gives a base rating of six, and FotMob's FAQ states no starting value.
Is a 7.0 on FotMob the same as 7.0 on Sofascore?
No source says it is, and a 2025 study says the systems are not interchangeable. Ball, Huynh and Varley report in their abstract that WhoScored, FotMob and Sofascore ratings capture different aspects of performance and are "not directly interchangeable". FotMob's FAQ gives no starting value to compare.
How long must a player be on the pitch to get a rating?
Sofascore and Flashscore both say ten minutes. Sofascore says 10 minutes of play are needed to generate the first ratings, and Flashscore says the player must spend at least ten minutes on the pitch, with extra time not counted. The WhoScored and FotMob pages we read give no minimum for a match rating.
Do ratings update during the match?
Yes, on the two pages that give a rhythm. Sofascore says its rating is updated 60 times during the match and a few more times after the final whistle. WhoScored says its ratings are updated live every 30 seconds. Those are two different statements, and neither is a general rule for all apps.
Why do newspapers rate players lower than apps?
Our sources show the gap in one sample but don't explain it. García-Fernández and Quian report in their abstract a mean of 6.76 for two European outlets, against 7.53 for Sofascore and 7.33 for Flashscore, across 60 players in 10 matches in 2024-25. A Portuguese study found that scales differ between newspapers.
More guides
- Home advantage in footballHome teams still win more than away teams, but the margin varies by season and league. What studies of matches without crowds found, and where they differ.
- What is xG (expected goals)?xG is the probability that a shot becomes a goal. How providers build it, why apps differ, what studies say about it as a predictor, and its limits.
- Why do score apps show different stats for the same match?Providers define possession, shots and xG in different ways, so apps can show different numbers. What the sources say, and what we can't confirm.
- What happens in live score apps when VAR cancels a goal?A goal alert can arrive and the goal can then be ruled out. What the VAR protocol and apps' help pages say about corrections, and what they leave out.
- Why are live scores ahead of or behind the TV?What UK sources say about TV and streaming delay, why an alert can land before or after the goal, and what a search for goal-alert timing tests found.
- How to follow non-league footballWhere to find National League, FA Trophy and FA Vase scores, how the Steps of the pyramid work, and which apps have public pages for them.